Thursday, January 31, 2013

Reviewing Christmas Movies.....

may be a bit of a late activity on my part, but as they say, better late than never! After watching some real beauties this year and reflecting on some of my past favorites, I can't help but take a shot on reviewing some of them before the end of the January and the Feast of the Presentation on February 2nd. After all, in some places of the world, the Christmas Season actually ends then! I'm taking full advantage of that fact, so please take the opportunity to mark some of these down on your list for next year!


The Nativity (1978) (religious/drama) (PG) (color, 98 min.):

    Madeleine Stowe stars as Mary of Nazareth, a pious young Jewish girl growing up in troubled times. Herod, the tyrannical puppet king installed by the Romans to rule Judea, has lost his mind. He thinks of nothing but the threat to his throne presented by the coming "Messiah" and raves about his dead wife, who he himself had executed. Three of his advisers are caught up in his insanity and forced to go in search of the "Messiah", a journey which takes them across the country and causes them to look into their own souls.

    Meanwhile, Mary is betrothed to Joseph, a soft-spoken carpenter with whom she is very much in love. But one day, when gathering water by a river, she has a visitation from an angel who tells her she will conceive and give birth to the Son of God. She says yes to will of God, even though she knows it will cause her much pain. The news of her pregnancy causes Joseph to become disillusioned and causes Mary's parents great anxiety. However, Joseph eventually has a visitation of his own, convincing him to take Mary as his wife. As her time to give birth draws near, the couple is forced to journey to Bethlehem for a census, and there, the greatest event in history unfolds.

    I enjoy this interpretation of the First Christmas Story very much. The relationship between Joseph and Mary is portrayed with sensitivity and a touch of gentle romance. She is shown as obedient to her parents’ ultimate decision, yet brave enough to bring up her preference for Joseph as well. He is shown as making her a small gift before the betrothal as a token of affection. They are shown doing the traditional Jewish betrothal dance and enjoying the fullness of the celebration. Also, when she lays back to give birth in the cave, Mary lovingly grasps Joseph's arm and he caresses her. I like these very human insights which bring these larger-than-life figures to life.

     Of course, there are some inaccuracy problems that pop up. For example, Herod did not call the census in order to search for the Christ Child to kill him; it was called by the Roman Emperor Augustus, who was famed for calling various censuses throughout his reign. Also, there is no evidence supporting the fact that Joseph had secret sympathies with the zealots. Then are the issues of "probability". For example, the idea that Mary should seek to marry before the prescribed time seems highly unlikely in that period. Nonetheless, watching this well-crafted movie is an excellent way to bring your mind to focus on the real "reason for the season" and why we celebrate it.

It's a Wonderful Life (1946) (inspirational/drama) (PG) (black & white, 130 min.):

    Jimmy Stewart stars as George Bailey, a man with big dreams about exploring and changing the world. However, his plans take a turn when his father dies and he is forced to stay in the sleepy little town of Bedford Falls to run his late father's business, the Bailey Building and Loan. Harassed by the greedy businessman, Mr. Potter, George labors to get decent housing for the financially strained residents of the town. He eventually marries his childhood sweetheart, Mary, and settles down to raise a large family.

     But George is still deeply unsettled, yearning for the dreams that have been stolen from him by circumstances. He becomes frustrated by his simple life, and envies his war-hero brother and childhood friends who achieved "great" things in his eyes. When his absent-minded Uncle Billy misplaces a large amount of money and the Building and Loan is threatened with bankruptcy, George finally snaps. Convinced that the world would be better off if he was never born, he plans on throwing himself in a river. But a visitor from Heaven prevents him, and gives him a chance to experience what the world if he had never been in it.

    This film is a Christmas classic because it combines light-hearted comedy and romance with forays into a world of darkness, despair, and inner conflict. For most of the film, the storyline is based on realism and being relatable for the average viewer. Then it takes a twist and becomes a Twilight-Zone-like, supernatural encounter tale with a touch of humor to alleviate the dark content. But the change in mood is executed deftly, and even the more fantastic scenes hold a sense of haunting realism.

    While the film is theologically inaccurate about angels (they are spirits - not deceased human beings!), it still poignantly demonstrates the workings of the angels and saints in our lives. Also, the story reveals that God was working through George's life the whole time, even though he felt that his life had no meaning. He affected more people than he realized and changed the world for the better. This should go a long way to demonstrate that no life is worthless. Director Frank Capra worked magic with this film, and the world is indebted to him for his contribution to the art of movie-making.

A Time to Remember (1987) (inspirational/drama) (G) (color, 88 min.):

     Ruben Gomez stars as Angelo Villano, an Italian-American boy in the 1950's who dreams of being a singer like his idol, Mario Lanza. But his father, who labors as a factory-worker every day to put bread on the table, thinks that singing is for "sissies" and would much prefer to see his son take an interest in football like the other boys. But Angelo finds support with his tough yet loving grandmother, Mama Theresa, and his local parish priest, Fr. Walsh. When Fr. Walsh introduces Angelo to a famous singing teacher who starts giving the boy voice lessons, Angelo's father becomes increasingly annoyed by his son's interest and eventually has him stop attending the lessons.

    Meanwhile, the local neighborhood boys bully Angelo for his interest in singing and his Italian ancestry. Fleeing one such encounter, he runs into the street and into the path of an oncoming car. Although he survives the accident, he loses his voice as a result of trauma. Also, his beloved Fr. Walsh has a fatal heart-attack, leaving the boy feeling more isolated than ever. But then on Christmas Eve, a cruel prank by some neighborhood bullies results in an unexpected miracle that restores Angelo's voice.

    This film is also a holiday favorite for my family. Since we have a fair share of Italian blood in our veins, it does hold a certain amount of fondness for us. Religion and family are portrayed as the bulwarks of the small American community, and various cultures are shown gradually becoming a part of the great melting pot. The storyline itself is very touching, especially the apparition of the (very Italian-looking) Holy Family and when Angelo sings "Ave Maria" at Christmas Mass.

    I find it interesting how Angelo is shown being hit at the exact same time that Fr. Walsh collapses from a heart-attack. The film flashes back and forth from one scene to the next several times to draw the parallel and almost indicate that Angelo's voice was intricately bound up in the encouragement of the priest. When he was gone, the boy's voice left him as well. As far as Mama Theresa is concerned, I do wish they had toned her down a bit, since she came off as quite pushy and rather hard to love at times. But I suppose that was all part of accurately portraying different aspects of Italian culture!

White Christmas (1954) (musical/romance/comedy) (G) (color, 120 min.):

     Bing Crosby stars as Bob Wallace, a captain in the U.S. Army fighting overseas during WWII. He puts on entertainment for the 151st Division with the help of his soldier buddy, Phil Davis, and the consent of their tough yet beloved commander, General Waverly. When their Christmas show is interrupted by an enemy attack and a wall nearly falls on Wallace, Davis rescues his friend and gets wounded in the arm in the process. Refusing to let Wallace forget this "special favor", Davis convinces him to take to the road with a duo act. They are an amazingly successful team. Then fate brings the Haynes Sisters, Betty and Judy, into their lives.

    Agreeing to see their "Sisters" act because their brother was their old mess sergeant, Wallace and Davis find themselves smitten by the beautiful and talented young women. Before long, they find themselves involved mix-up involving a stained rug, an angry landlord, and a sheriff, that results in them joining the girls on a train bound for Vermont. When they arrive, they find that there is a surprising lack of snow and that the inn the girls had booked is run by the now-retired Gen. Waverly. There desire to help "the old man" backfires when Betty Haynes mistakenly believes Wallace is trying to make Waverly an object of sympathy for personal gain. But all comes right in the end, complete with a "White Christmas" to boot!

    A holiday classic from yesteryear, this film has a variety of attractive qualities. It has music, comedy, romance, and a touching display of loyalty between the 151st Division and General Waverly. Also, the setting of the Vermont Inn is charming as are the mix of quirky characters with good intentions. Many of the songs are vividly imprinted in my mind, especially "Sisters", "The Old Man," "The Best Things Happen While Your Dancing", "Snow", "Count Your Blessings Instead of Sheep", "Gee, I Wish I Was Back in the Army", and of course, "White Christmas."

    Unfortunately, there is a down side to the film as well. Show girls dressed in appallingly skimpy attire, immodest dances, thinly-veiled sexual innuendos, etc. make the otherwise wholesome production somewhat tarnished. It's a real pity, since it always makes me pause before endorsing the film completely, although it has been a favorite since I was very young. I would suggest fast-forwarding some of the long dance numbers, especially for family viewing. Other than that, I really think it's a fun holiday musical that continues to get laughs and tears out of my family year after year.

The Sound of Music (1965) (musical/romance) (G) (color, 174 min.):

    Julie Andrews stars as Maria, a young Austrian novice who decides to emerge into the world once more to discern her true calling. She takes a job as a governess for the widowed Col. Von Trapp, earning the affection of his seven motherless children and endowing them with a love of music. The austere Von Trapp in initially put off by her methods of handling the children, who he previously reared with military-like discipline. But soon he begins to warm to the vivacious young women, even though he is simultaneously planning to marry a wealthy baroness.
   
     Just in time, however, Von Trapp realizes that his heart truly belongs to Maria, and the two are married. The family then forms a singing group which gains much acclaim in Austria. But this happy time is short-lived. Nazi Germany annexes Austria and invites Col. Von Trapp to serve in the military of the Third Reich. When he tries to back out, he is reminded the punishment will forthcoming for him and his family should he refuse. They plan on escaping across the Alps, but the Nazis are hot on their trail. With one more card to play, the family makes a final musical performance....with a surprise finale.

     This film is one of the most beloved musicals of all time and one of my personal favorites. Not only does it have abundant charm, but it also has a twist of danger that lends a sense of reality to the tale and makes viewers feel for the Von Trapp family all the more. Also, the romance between Col. Von Trapp and Maria, as well as the rekindled relationship between Von Trapp and his children, is heart-warming. Classic musical numbers, such as "The Sound of Music", "My Favorite Things", "I Am 16 Going on 17",  "Edelweiss", etc., abound, and the majestic scenery shot on-location in Austria is gorgeous. While this is not a Christmas film per se, it has a very festive feel to it, and my family often watches it over the Yuletide.

    One of the main issues with this delightful film is the way historical facts are tampered with to make a good story. The real Col. Von Trapp was not the austere character depicted in the movie; in fact, his children have verified that he is the one who first taught them to sing and love music. Also, while the Von Trapp Family Singers did indeed flee from the Nazis, they didn't cross the Alps. If they had done so from their location in Austria, they would have round up nearby one of Hitler's summer pleasure retreats! However, the courage of Col. Von Trapp in refusing to accept a Nazi commission is accurately represented, and the beauty of the product speaks for itself.


I'll try and catch up with the times by rounding up some romance flicks for St. Valentine's Day in February.....;-)


A Scene from the Film The Nativity


11 comments:

  1. Pearl, I confess that deep within me I have a burning desire to kick Tiny Tim's little crutch out from under him.


    - Mack in Texas

    ReplyDelete
  2. I enjoyed these reviews - "It's a Wonderful Life" is the ultimate pro-life movie, isn't it? The alternate world Clarence shows us really drives home all the world is missing because of all the children who were never born - at the same time leading us all to appreciate God's greatest gift.

    "The Sound of Music" is my personal favorite musical of all time, for reasons that are too extensive to go into here. Ever read Maria's book or seen the stage version? (Although as an extremely technical person, I appreciated your pointing out that it technically isn't a Christmas movie, because it isn't.)

    As a Catholic singer, will have to try to remember to see "A Time to Remember" next year. And I have to ask - do you have a favorite film adaptation of "A Christmas Carol"? It's my Dad's favorite Christmas story. Also, have you ever seen "Miracle on 34th Street"? (I'm talking about the classic 1947 film, not any of the four or more remakes.)

    - Katherine

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hmm.....Mack, it sounds like you have a bad case of the Christmas blues, and I can only assume it may have been brought on by these overly-late reviews! My humble apologies ;-)

    By the way, since you've been such a loyal follower for so many months, would you like to exchange emails somehow?

    I'm glad you liked the selection, Katherine. I agree that "It's a Wonderful Life" really does have an excellent pro-life message about the way one person can effect the world. Do try to get a hold of "A Time to Remember" next year. It is a really sweet story about Catholic singers.

    And yes, you're right about the fact that "The Sound of Music" isn't really a "Christmas" film, except for the fact that my family often watches it at Christmas. I think the screen play writers really overlooked the marvelous possibility of inserting a "Christmas in Austria" scene!

    Yes, I have seen the original version of "Miracle on 34th Street", but it was quite a few years ago. I recall it had a very cute storyline about the "real" Santa Claus and a little girl who wanted her own house. As for "A Christmas Carol", I have seen several different versions, but I can't differentiate them from the top of my head! I'll take a shot at them next year!

    God Bless,
    Pearl

    ReplyDelete
  4. There are two (well, possibly three) versions of "A Christmas Carol" my family and I tend to watch around the holidays. The first is "Scrooge" from the 1950's--in my opinion, it is one of the best adaptations ever, and Alistair Sim is the perfect Ebenezer Scrooge. The second will no doubt make you laugh--the Muppet Christmas Carol. Hey, it's got Gonzo as the narrator (Charles Dickens), Kermit as Bob Crachit, and Rizzo as himself; how can you go wrong with a combination like that? And the third will just have you shake your head...the Doctor Who version. In this version, the Doctor's friends Amy and Rory are trapped on a spaceship that's about to crash, and the one man who can help them refuses to do so simply because he is a curmudgeony old grouch. The Doctor decides that the easiest way to fix this problem is to use his trusty time machine to go back in time and give this man a happier past, but the plan tragically misfires. Not to worry, though; there's still a happy ending! It's not meant as anything serious, just a piece of lighthearted fun that the show's head writer wrote for Christmas one year.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Pearl and Emerald!

      I've seen countless adaptations of Scrooge's story on both stage and screen, because it is my Dad's favorite story of all time. Musicals, straight plays, black and white, modern adaptations... you name it. (Though I have yet to see the Muppets and Dr. Who versions.) There is one version that definitely doesn't make it a total horror story, and that's the version my local community theatre does every other year. We sing religious carols right in the public theatre - it's awesome!

      Also glad to hear Mack can admit to liking "The Sound of Music." : )

      - Katherine

      Delete
  5. (Third attempt -- AOL is NOT my friend today)

    Most Excellent Pearl,

    You know how I love movies with happy endings -- TITANIC and MOBY DICK come to mind. :)

    Yes on the email; not sure how to do that, though.

    Katherine (my mother's name and my godchild's name), as a Total Guy I'm not supposed to admit that I love THE SOUND OF MUSIC, but, yes, it's a favorite.

    - Mack in Texas

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have to laugh at your Titanic comment, Mack...my mom said the only reason she ever watched that movie was to watch the boat sink.

      Delete
    2. The boat certainly had more personality than Jack and his script of cliches', although those who follow popular culture more than I do say that Leonardo DiCaprio really is a good actor given the right parts.

      Delete
  6. @Emerald: I have seen the Alistair Sim version of "A Christmas Carol". It was quite good. I've also watched another one that was in black-and-white and another that was in a play format, but I'm not sure who the leading actors were in either version. I'm curious to find out if there are any decent modern Scrooge adaptations, or if every recent production has gone down the track of making it a total horror story. It sounds like I need to check out the Muppets and Dr. Who.....;-)

    @Mack: Ah, yes, those flicks had oodles of daisies and lollipops....LOL! Honestly, I do love films with happy (or at least hopeful or inspirational) endings, and I usually consider a very "sad ending" a pretty "bad ending". As for "The Sound of Music", I wouldn't say is just a "girl thing". As I've elaborated in the past, I feel that men should really learn to get more sensative about things instead of being so excessively "Macho"!

    You can put your email up in a comment to the blog which I will receive privately before it can be published. Then I'll just delete the comment to keep your information private.

    God Bless,
    Pearl

    ReplyDelete
  7. (email address removed)

    Dear Pearl,

    Okay, but if this gets into the hands of Dan Brown and his skulking albino monks it's the end of the free world and the lights will go out all over Europe, or at least in New Orleans' SuperDuperDome.

    Life is good.

    -Mack in Texas

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey pearl!

    Thanks for these reviews, I had tried to comment on this before, but something funky happened and I think the post was lost!

    I had never heard of this version of the Nativity, thanks for the info. Stowe is a good actress.

    As for "Its a wonderful life" - there is a small independent cinema near where I live and they show it every Christmas. I am ways tempted to see it there - the problem is, the cinema seems designed for pygmies (!) and I spend the whole time with my knees jammed uncomfortably into the seat in front!

    So I guess that DVD will be the best option for me!

    I look forward your romance flick reviews!

    Bye for now
    GWright

    ReplyDelete